BERLIN — The German authorities has sharply rejected accusations by U.S. Well being Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. claiming that it has been sidelining affected person autonomy, particularly throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.
“The statements made by the US Secretary of Well being are utterly unfounded, factually incorrect, and should be rejected,” German Well being Minister Nina Warken mentioned in an announcement late Saturday.
Kennedy mentioned in a video put up earlier on Saturday that he had despatched the German minister a letter based mostly on studies popping out of Germany that the federal government was “limiting folks’s talents to behave on their very own convictions after they face medical choices.”
The American well being secretary mentioned that “I’ve realized that greater than a thousand German physicians and hundreds of their sufferers now face prosecution and punishment for issuing exemptions from sporting masks or getting COVID-19 vaccines throughout the pandemic.”
Warken rejected Kennedy’s claims, saying that “throughout the coronavirus pandemic, there was by no means any obligation on the medical career to manage COVID-19 vaccinations. Anybody who didn’t wish to provide vaccinations for medical, moral, or private causes was not liable to prosecution, nor did they need to worry sanctions.”
Kennedy didn’t give present particular examples or say which studies he was referring to however added that “in my letter, I defined that Germany is concentrating on physicians who put their sufferers first and punishing residents for making their very own medical decisions.”
He concluded that “the German authorities is now violating the sacred affected person doctor relationship, changing it’s a harmful system that makes physicians enforcers of state insurance policies.”
Kennedy mentioned that in his letter he made clear that “Germany has the chance and the duty to appropriate this trajectory, to revive medical autonomy, to finish politically motivated prosecutions.”
Warken identified that there have been no skilled bans or fines for not getting vaccinated.
“Felony prosecution was solely pursued in circumstances of fraud and doc forgery, such because the issuance of false vaccination certificates or faux masks certificates,” the minister mentioned.
She additionally clarified that normally in Germany “sufferers are additionally free to determine which remedy they want to bear.”
Former German Well being Minister Karl Lauterbach, who was in cost throughout the pandemic, additionally replied, addressing Kennedy straight on X saying that he “ought to maintain well being issues in his personal nation. Brief life expectancy, excessive prices, tens of hundreds of drug deaths and homicide victims.”
“In Germany, docs usually are not punished by the federal government for issuing false medical certificates. In our nation, the courts are unbiased,” Lauterbach wrote.
Whereas a majority of Germans have been desperate to get vaccinated towards the COVID-19 virus throughout the pandemic, there have been additionally protests by a small minority of vaccine skeptics in Germany which have been typically supported by far-right actions.
